02 June 2009

Plagiasi/Inspirasi

Banyak orang yang masih nggak paham perbedaan Plagiasi sama Terinspirasi. Masih nyaru istilahnya. Sekarang kalo samaan dikit aja, dibilangnya "Ah plagiat lo!"

Jujur, gue juga masih nggak ngerti. Kalo suruh ngebedain, gue juga pasti bingung sendiri.

Tapi gue gerah sama kabar yang beredar akhir-akhir ini. Ya tentang D'Masiv lah, Kuburan band lah, et cetera et cetera.

Pasti tau kan tentang kasus lagu-lagu D'Masiv yang katanya SEMUA lagunya copycat?
Pas gue search di YT, apalah, cuma intronya oke emang mirip tapi setelahnya kan enggak. Biasa aja. Gue bilang itu salah satu dari contoh terinspirasi. Masih banyak artis Indonesia yang JELAS-JELAS plagiat. Contohnya: (taken from Desak's blog)

Do Bee Do - Gita Gutawa = Do Bee Do - Freshly Ground

ITU BARU NAMANYA PLAGIAT, tapi kenapa cuma D'Masiv sih yang di jelek-jelekin? Bukannya gue ngebela, tapi, lo liat aja deh. Masyarakat juga bisa nilai sendiri yang bener yang mana. Mereka dengan asiknya ngata-ngatain D'Masiv sampah, D'Masiv nggak layak dapet platinum album, bla bla bla. Gue bilang itu cuma bagian dari iri hati doang. Gue sebagai musisi, walaupun masih amatiran, tapi ngerti juga lah perasaan mereka gimana. Lo kira bikin lagu gampang, dul??

Trus yang lagi hot-hotnya kasus lagu Vierra yang mirip sama lagunya Lost Prophets yang Rooftop. Yaudah sih orang cuma mirip dikit santai aja dong, heerrrrr kesel nih udah di ubun-ubun.
Dan sekarang, banyak orang yang ngata-ngatain Kuburan plagiat gara-gara muka personilnya di cat kaya musisi KISS. KAN CUMA MUKANYA DOANG KENAPA LO JADI SEWOT ZXCZXZCXZ@!#$%.

Itu baru terinspirasi. Bukan plagiasi.

Makanya kalo ngomong dipikir dulu, jangan main asal samber aja!

Kesel.

9 comments:

  1. It may sound somewhat familiar but come on people…., its music!!! There are only 12 notes to work with here and it gonna cross its own path now and then.
    BUT……
    there’s a tiny differencies between plagiatirized and coincedenced…..this tiny thing has a big meaning from the art of playing and creating music…
    BUT…..
    soo many similarities in their album???…could we say this are coincidences????? come on……..
    think logic…..then, you can post some word…
    or ya shud STFU to keep your face not in a mud…..

    ReplyDelete
  2. @nuy
    yg ttg d'masiv apa gita gutawa?

    @anonymous
    I just hate the way people judge them. Okay the deal is if they WERE really plagiarized, it's just on the intro of the song for God's sake!

    ReplyDelete
  3. udahlah, yg penting olip inspirational.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Janit
    you're absolutely not understand :
    what art/s is/are....
    music is an art...
    originality in art is a MUST..
    ariginality is music/s also is a MUST...even just in intro/reff/lead/etc....
    GROW UP...if you want indonesian musician/s has/have progression in their experince/s...

    I THINK....
    your head already in a mud for a long time before "wanna be" band
    raised their flag in Indonesia..
    frnky speaking, if you want comment some post...you should have experiences on it, or at least you try it for sometimes than you could post some comment or even judge related to it..

    SOO....
    S.T.F.U

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Anonymous
    Everyone deserve to have their own opinion, including ME. So I wont shut the fuck out of my mouth because that is what I think. Take it or leave it. This is my blog, I write what I wanna write. thanks.

    ReplyDelete